Of course, as soon as I post I find what the issue is. However, I can’t figure out why mine is different than demo.
In style.css, line 654 padding is set to 60. But in the demo, with Chrome Developer Tools it shows 60, but its marked out. Did I somewhere turn off a setting that disabled 60?
Seeking this out was the only change to CSS I made, so I don’t believe it was through there that I messed it up.