If you use our blog template Blog instead of current Posts Page, this issue does not occur. I noticed that you have set the revolution slider for this post –
http://www.subtielman.com/wp-admin/post.php?post=4251&action=edit
which made the slider to be set for the page 3 since this is the first post to appear there. I have removed the same and now the issue is resolved.
I will take a deeper look at this issue in my dev installs and prevent this in future updates. Thanks.